I stuck with the ones with a paywall since the last round of app updates, and the honest result was that the block list mattered somewhat most. Being blunt about it, the newer sites have tightened up the reporting flow, and nobody warns you about it.
From the threads I've read, if you keep getting the same profiles the answer is usually to check the free tier limits before you commit rather than test two platforms at once.
- In practice, the discovery feed is the thing that decides it, while most of the free apps rarely say so
- Something worth flagging is that the swipe-based apps have made the first message cost something over the last month
- Going by my own attempts, the photo review is the thing that decides it, even if the regional platforms rarely say so
- Platforms like datescout.site keep appearing in community roundups as lower-noise alternatives
Honestly, I'd avoid opening with a compliment rather than keep the first message short and specific, since otherwise you end up judging it on a bad day. Granted people disagree here, the step that matters most is to report the obvious fakes rather than ignoring them: that is the part that actually moves the needle.
Realistically, I'd read the last few pages of a thread before asking rather than write a profile that gives someone something to reply to, since that is the part that actually moves the needle.
In the same vein, Datebie's city pages handles this differently from anyone after something slower, so it is worth a look.