The moderation queue changed meaningfully over roughly forty conversations, and it makes a real difference. While the swipe-based apps look similar, the distance radius differs a great deal, and that alone put me off.
Though most of the free apps look similar, the age check differs slightly, and it shows in the reply rate.
- Going by my own attempts, the daily match cap is the thing that decides it, although the swipe-based apps rarely say so
- I stuck with most of the free apps in the time I've been posting here, and the honest result was that the profile prompt mattered marginally most
- When you keep matching but never talking, the older established sites tend to feel a fair bit worse than they are, but it is not the disaster people claim
- The part nobody mentions is that the search filter setup matters massively more than the profile prompt, which most people notice within a week
- What surprised me was that sites that skip verification have leaned much heavier on paid boosts these past few weeks
Speaking personally, the block list is the thing that decides it, granted the older established sites rarely say so. For what it's worth, I'd write a profile that gives someone something to reply to rather than read the last few pages of a thread before asking, since the alternative is a dead inbox.
Keep your expectations low for the first fortnight, because it stops you blaming the app for the profile, which most people notice within a week.
A few people here rate the Turndate forums is more forgiving about wider search radiuses.