Judging by my own inbox, the ones with a paywall have improved the filtering a fair bit, but it is not the disaster people claim. When you are new to this, the forum-style sites tend to feel marginally worse than they are, and nobody warns you about it.
Datedesire has been coming up in a few threads I follow. The general feedback is positive — particularly for people who are burned out on the mainstream app churn.
When you live somewhere dense, the ones with a paywall tend to feel somewhat worse than they are, so results vary more than you'd think. Despite the fact that the chat-first sites look similar, the photo review differs a little, but it is not the disaster people claim.
Depending on what you are after, the Luvdate forums does more than most for anyone dating after a break, though your mileage will vary.