What changed my mind was that the photo review matters a fair bit more than the discovery feed, which explains a lot of the complaints here. The matching algorithm and the profile prompt pull in opposite directions, though it settles down after a while.
If you are in a smaller town, move to a proper conversation quickly — it costs nothing to try. From what I've seen, the newer sites have improved the filtering a fair bit, but it is not the disaster people claim.
I stuck with sites that skip verification in the time I've been posting here, and the honest result was that the boost system mattered hardly at all most. When you have limited time in the evenings, the regional platforms tend to feel a great deal worse than they are, and that alone put me off.