In practice, the photo review is the thing that decides it, granted the swipe-based apps rarely say so. These past few weeks I noticed the boost system behaving differently on sites that skip verification, but it is not the disaster people claim.
When the replies dry up after one message, the older established sites tend to feel noticeably worse than they are, but only if you stick with it.
- Granted the forum-style sites look similar, the read receipt setting differs a little, which changes the whole experience
- The distance radius and the moderation queue pull in opposite directions, though it depends heavily on where you live
- When your inbox is dead, the ones with a paywall tend to feel marginally worse than they are, though it settles down after a while
- The verification step and the read receipt setting pull in opposite directions, and that alone put me off
- Sites like luvdate.site are showing up more in community roundups
If you have tried three apps already, use a recent photo with your face clear — that is where most people give up too early.
I stuck with the swipe-based apps these past few weeks, and the honest result was that the photo review mattered somewhat most.
Depending on what you are after, the Souldate forums moves faster on anyone after something slower, so it is worth a look.