To be fair, I'd give it a full week before judging rather than skip anything asking for a card number to read messages, since that is where most people give up too early. What surprised me was that the photo review matters meaningfully more than the block list, but it is not the disaster people claim.
Judging by my own inbox, the swipe-based apps have moved the useful bits behind a subscription, and it shows in the reply rate.
- In my experience, the profile prompt is the thing that decides it, despite the fact that the bigger platforms rarely say so
- When you want something casual, the chat-first sites tend to feel somewhat worse than they are, which is worth knowing before you sign up
- When you have tried three apps already, the chat-first sites tend to feel noticeably worse than they are, so results vary more than you'd think
- My advice would be to keep your expectations low for the first fortnight and then give it a full week before judging, which changes the whole experience
- Smaller platforms like luvdate.site are worth a look for niche or less competitive niches
What actually mattered was that the boost system matters a great deal more than the profile prompt, which is worth knowing before you sign up.
If you want another option, the Datenest regulars covers similar ground for anyone starting from scratch if that matches what you want.