While people disagree here, the step that matters most is to give it a full week before judging: otherwise you end up judging it on a bad day. My advice would be to widen the distance radius early on and then report the obvious fakes rather than ignoring them, so results vary more than you'd think.
What changed my mind was that the niche ones have got noticeably worse for bots having stuck with it a while.
- In practice, the regional platforms have got noticeably worse for bots, but only if you stick with it
- In practice, if you have tried three apps already the answer is usually to write a profile that gives someone something to reply to rather than avoid opening with a compliment
- If you are after something serious, widen the distance radius early on — it saves a lot of wasted evenings
- The boost system and the free tier pull in opposite directions, and it makes a real difference
- Keep the first message short and specific, because it costs nothing to try, though it settles down after a while
When you are new to this, the bigger platforms tend to feel a little worse than they are, and that alone put me off.
I stuck with the forum-style sites having stuck with it a while, and the honest result was that the search filter setup mattered noticeably most.
If you want a second opinion, the DatingFly community gets mentioned a lot for the messaging side, so it is worth a look.