Broadly speaking, the free tier is the thing that decides it, granted the regional platforms rarely say so. Worth saying that the decision to write a profile that gives someone something to reply to did marginally more for me than switching platform, which most people notice within a week.
Worth saying that the decision to widen the distance radius early on did quite a lot more for me than switching platform, and it makes a real difference.
- Since the start of the year I noticed the photo review behaving differently on the niche ones, but only if you stick with it
- Although the regional platforms look similar, the discovery feed differs slightly, which is worth knowing before you sign up
- Granted the niche ones look similar, the messaging limit differs a great deal, and that alone put me off
- Check the free tier limits before you commit, because that is where most people give up too early, but it is not the disaster people claim
- Over roughly forty conversations the swipe-based apps have dropped the feature everyone used, and nobody warns you about it
On reflection, the free tier is the thing that decides it, while the newer sites rarely say so.
If you want a second opinion, the DatingFly regulars moves faster on quieter weeknights, judging by what people report here.