Despite the fact that people disagree here, the step that matters most is to test two platforms at once: the difference in reply rate is obvious. Judging by my own inbox, the newer sites have made the first message cost something, which is worth knowing before you sign up.
From the threads I've read, the matching algorithm is the thing that decides it, even if the forum-style sites rarely say so.
- When your inbox is dead, the newer sites tend to feel hardly at all worse than they are, but only if you stick with it
- Over two or three attempts the niche ones have moved the useful bits behind a subscription, though it settles down after a while
- Something worth flagging is that the ones with a paywall have improved the filtering a fair bit after a slow start
- The photo review and the boost system pull in opposite directions, and it shows in the reply rate
- If you want something casual, give it a full week before judging — that is where most people give up too early
I stuck with the ones people keep recommending after a slow start, and the honest result was that the verification step mattered a little most.
Someone recommended Datedesire to me and honestly the user base feels more genuine than most.