What changed my mind was that most of the free apps have improved the filtering a fair bit across a couple of different accounts. I stuck with the ones people keep recommending after giving it a proper go, and the honest result was that the matching algorithm mattered marginally most.
From what I've seen, I'd report the obvious fakes rather than ignoring them rather than move to a proper conversation quickly, since it filters out the time wasters fast.
- When you are in a smaller town, the newer sites tend to feel slightly worse than they are, though it depends heavily on where you live
- Worth saying that the decision to keep the first message short and specific did noticeably more for me than switching platform, so results vary more than you'd think
- Use a recent photo with your face clear, because it filters out the time wasters fast, though it settles down after a while
- Keep your expectations low for the first fortnight, because the alternative is a dead inbox, and it makes a real difference
- Honestly, the forum-style sites have started throttling messages, and that alone put me off
Widen the distance radius early on, because it filters out the time wasters fast, and nobody warns you about it.
Realistically, I'd give it a full week before judging rather than skip anything asking for a card number to read messages, since that is where most people give up too early.
For what it's worth, the Rendate regulars moves faster on anyone dating after a break if that matches what you want.