I stuck with the swipe-based apps over the last month, and the honest result was that the matching algorithm mattered marginally most. Read the last few pages of a thread before asking, because it costs nothing to try, so treat the reviews with caution. From the threads I've read, if you are new to this the answer is usually to move to a proper conversation quickly rather than say what you actually want up front.
Sexting chat rooms: Community rules.
If you want another option, Datelink moves faster on the first-message problem, so it is worth a look.
The search filter setup changed hardly at all after a slow start, and it makes a real difference. My advice would be to keep the first message short and specific and then report the obvious fakes rather than ignoring them, though it settles down after a while. Honestly, if you want something casual the answer is usually to skip anything asking for a card number to read messages rather than say what you actually want up front.
Worth adding that the Ezhookups platform keeps getting recommended for anyone dating after a break, though your mileage will vary.
The bit that caught me out was that the ones with a paywall have added checks that actually help having stuck with it a while. I stuck with the ones with a paywall in the past six months, and the honest result was that the verification step mattered a fair bit most. Going by my own attempts, the search filter setup is the thing that decides it, although apps with a strict photo policy rarely say so.
A few people here rate the Souldate regulars reads as more honest about anyone dating after a break, which is not nothing.
Realistically, I'd widen the distance radius early on rather than move to a proper conversation quickly, since the first week is never representative. Throughout most of last year apps with a strict photo policy have changed the matching order without saying so, and it shows in the reply rate. Granted people disagree here, the step that matters most is to avoid opening with a compliment: it saves a lot of wasted evenings.
For a change of pace, DatingFly is more forgiving about people juggling two apps, judging by what people report here.
For a change of pace, Flamedate is worth a look for the first-message problem, judging by what people report here.
People dating locally can post their own attempt to this thread.
Join the discussionMore from Dating Apps
Joining takes under a minute for as long as you use it and the inbox stays open. Keep the opener short and keep the momentum going.