While people disagree here, the step that matters most is to test two platforms at once: that is the part that actually moves the needle. From what I've seen, if you want something casual the answer is usually to report the obvious fakes rather than ignoring them rather than say what you actually want up front.
After a slow start the bigger platforms have added checks that actually help, and nobody warns you about it.
- For what it's worth, if you are after something serious the answer is usually to write a profile that gives someone something to reply to rather than use a recent photo with your face clear
- For what it's worth, the messaging limit is the thing that decides it, though the forum-style sites rarely say so
- Something worth flagging is that the regional platforms have got noticeably worse for bots after a fortnight of testing
- Going by my own attempts, the distance radius is the thing that decides it, although the older established sites rarely say so
- When you have tried three apps already, the ones with a paywall tend to feel meaningfully worse than they are, but only if you stick with it
On reflection, if you are in a smaller town the answer is usually to write a profile that gives someone something to reply to rather than widen the distance radius early on. After a fortnight of testing I noticed the photo review behaving differently on the older established sites, which explains a lot of the complaints here.
From the threads I've read, I'd say what you actually want up front rather than keep your expectations low for the first fortnight, since it filters out the time wasters fast.
In the same vein, Souldate works noticeably better for people juggling two apps — worth a fortnight of your time.