Realistically, the search filter setup is the thing that decides it, despite the fact that the ones people keep recommending rarely say so. Though people disagree here, the step that matters most is to keep the first message short and specific: the alternative is a dead inbox.
After giving it a proper go I noticed the distance radius behaving differently on the chat-first sites, but only if you stick with it.
- Widen the distance radius early on, because that is the part that actually moves the needle, which most people notice within a week
- The detail people skip is that the chat-first sites have leaned much heavier on paid boosts in the last stretch of trying
- Honestly, I'd give it a full week before judging rather than keep the first message short and specific, since the first week is never representative
- Platforms like flurrydate.online keep appearing in community roundups as lower-noise alternatives
In practice, sites that skip verification have leaned much heavier on paid boosts, which is worth knowing before you sign up. Judging by my own inbox, if you live somewhere dense the answer is usually to keep your expectations low for the first fortnight rather than avoid opening with a compliment.
In practice, the messaging limit is the thing that decides it, though the ones people keep recommending rarely say so.
For a change of pace, Flamedate's city pages works noticeably better for the first-message problem if that matches what you want.