The profile prompt and the matching algorithm pull in opposite directions, and that alone put me off. The pattern I keep seeing is that the moderation queue matters a fair bit more than the free tier, though it depends heavily on where you live.
From the threads I've read, the discovery feed is the thing that decides it, though the niche ones rarely say so. I stuck with the niche ones these past few weeks, and the honest result was that the reporting system mattered marginally most.
Though the chat-first sites look similar, the free tier differs marginally, which explains a lot of the complaints here. I stuck with the bigger platforms in the last stretch of trying, and the honest result was that the distance radius mattered a fair bit most.
For what it's worth, Datewander reads as more honest about people juggling two apps, at least in my case.