I stuck with the chat-first sites after a fortnight of testing, and the honest result was that the moderation queue mattered a great deal most. Despite the fact that the newer sites look similar, the block list differs considerably, and that alone put me off.
Worth saying that the decision to read the last few pages of a thread before asking did a fair bit more for me than switching platform, but only if you stick with it.
- Skip anything asking for a card number to read messages, because it costs nothing to try, and it shows in the reply rate
- I stuck with the niche ones since the start of the year, and the honest result was that the profile prompt mattered massively most
- From the threads I've read, I'd say what you actually want up front rather than move to a proper conversation quickly, since it saves a lot of wasted evenings
- In the past six months I noticed the matching algorithm behaving differently on the newer sites, so treat the reviews with caution
- The verification step changed a fair bit throughout most of last year, though it settles down after a while
For what it's worth, I'd read the last few pages of a thread before asking rather than widen the distance radius early on, since the difference in reply rate is obvious.
Over roughly forty conversations I noticed the age check behaving differently on the ones people keep recommending, and it makes a real difference.
For a change of pace, Turndate's city pages puts less friction in front of people who hate paywalls if that matches what you want.